Movie Reviews - In theater

There are romantic comedies that want to reinvent the genre, romantic comedies that desperately want you to believe love can fix every terrible decision you’ve made, and then there’s You, Me & Tuscany, a movie that basically grabs two attractive people, throws them into Italy, pours some wine, manufactures a ridiculous misunderstanding, and says, “Come on, you know exactly why you’re here.”

And, dammit, it works.

Director Kat Coiro (Marry Me, She-Hulk: Attorney at Law) understands the assignment from the opening moments and never pretends this is anything other than glossy, unapologetically ridiculous date-night escapism. Never mind that a movie called You, Me & Tuscany spends a suspicious amount of time showing off Rome. Italy is Italy when the lighting is this good and everyone looks like they wandered out of a vacation advertisement.

Halle Bailey stars as Anna, an aspiring chef whose life has stalled somewhere between bad decisions and absolutely no plan whatsoever. After losing both her house-sitting gig and temporary roof over her head, she meets Matteo (Lorenzo de Moor), learns that his family has an empty villa in Tuscany, and makes the completely rational decision to fly across the Atlantic and squat there without his permission. Because romantic comedy. Things get considerably more complicated when Matteo’s mother Gabriella (Isabella Ferrari) arrives and Anna, rather than admitting she’s basically a very charming trespasser, allows everyone to believe she is Matteo’s fiancée. Then Michael (Regé-Jean Page) enters the picture and, because the universe apparently wants Anna rewarded for increasingly questionable choices, he looks like Regé-Jean Page. At that point, honesty never stood a chance.

Bailey is enormously likable here, giving Anna enough warmth and vulnerability to keep her from becoming irritating when the screenplay requires her to make yet another decision no functioning adult should make. More importantly, she and Page have the chemistry necessary to sell this nonsense, and Page knows exactly what movie he’s in, playing Michael with just enough uptight irritation to make his inevitable thawing enjoyable. The supporting cast is equally game. Lorenzo de Moor brings easy charm to Matteo, Isabella Ferrari gives Gabriella genuine warmth, Paolo Sassanelli and Stefania Casini add considerably to the Italian-family atmosphere, and Aziza Scott gets plenty of mileage out of Claire, Anna’s friend and occasional long-distance voice of sanity. Even Nia Vardalos pops up, because apparently Italian romantic comedies now require her presence by international law. It’s a solid ensemble from top to bottom, and nobody seems embarrassed about leaning into the silliness.

And silly it absolutely is.

You, Me & Tuscany operates in that wonderful romantic-comedy universe where one honest thirty-second conversation could end the movie before the appetizers arrive, so naturally nobody has it. Lies stack upon lies, coincidences arrive precisely when needed, misunderstandings become increasingly elaborate, and gorgeous Italian locations appear whenever the screenplay needs another shot of people realizing they might be falling in love. Coiro keeps everything moving with enough energy and self-awareness that resisting it eventually feels pointless. Sure, Tuscany occasionally seems like a supporting player in a movie considerably more interested in Rome than its title would suggest, but complaining about geographical accuracy here feels like complaining that the handsome British lawyer is too handsome. This is fantasy, baby. Pour another glass.

There are absolutely better romantic comedies, smarter romantic comedies, and certainly more believable romantic comedies, but You, Me & Tuscany isn’t trying to knock When Harry Met Sally... off the shelf. It wants two hours of your evening, preferably with someone you like sitting beside you, and promises attractive people, beautiful Italy, good food, romantic complications and absolutely nothing resembling the problems waiting outside your front door. Sometimes that is more than enough. Bailey and Page make the central romance work, the supporting cast keeps things lively, and Coiro delivers the whole ridiculous package with the appropriate amount of sunshine, charm and cinematic bullshit.

You, Me & Tuscany is date-night escapism at its most shamelessly manufactured—and I mean that as a compliment. Turn off your brain, ignore how much Rome wandered into a movie called Tuscany, and enjoy the damn vacation.

It is now streaming on Peacock and is available to purchase.

MPAA Rating: PG-13.
Runtime: 105 mins
Director: Kat Coiro
Writer: Ryan and Kristin Engle 
Cast: Halle Bailey; Regé-Jean Page; Lorenzo de Moor
Genre: Romance | Comedy
Tagline: She came for the past, and got lost in the sauce
Memorable Movie Quote: 
Distributor: Universal
Official Site:
Release Date: April 10, 2026
DVD/Blu-ray Release Date:
Synopsis: When a woman crashes at an empty Italian villa posing as the owner's fiancée, she discovers an unexpected romance that could transform her life.