In Theaters and Digital

There is something inherently suspicious about people who are too nice. Not kind, necessarily, but agreeable in that frictionless, smiling way that suggests either a pyramid scheme or something much worse. Peter Stylianou’s The Nice Ones understands that discomfort and builds an effective little nightmare around it. Instead of announcing its horror with monsters at the window or blood on the walls, the film asks us to become afraid of politeness. A smile lasts a little too long. An argument disappears when there absolutely should be one. People who once irritated each other suddenly behave as if they have achieved enlightenment. For Kate, trapped in the middle of it, everyone becoming better people might be the clearest indication that something has gone terribly wrong.

Joelle Rae plays Kate, who accompanies her boyfriend and his friends on a retreat to the countryside, where isolation quickly becomes one of the movie’s most useful weapons. Strange lights appear in the sky, but Stylianou wisely understands that the lights themselves are not nearly as interesting as what happens afterward. The people around Kate begin changing. They become calmer, more understanding and almost aggressively reasonable, which leaves Kate occupying the uncomfortable position traditionally reserved for characters in paranoid thrillers: she sees what everyone else either cannot or will not acknowledge. Rae handles that uncertainty well because she never needs to turn Kate into a screaming genre heroine. Her fear comes largely from watching familiar people remain physically recognizable while something essential behind their eyes seems to have shifted.

There is obvious DNA from Invasion of the Body Snatchers and The Thing running through The Nice Ones, but Stylianou finds enough of his own territory to keep the film from becoming another variation on either. The clever twist is that these people do not become cold, openly hostile copies of themselves. They become nicer. The film’s idea of “false light”—something potentially malevolent presenting itself as benevolent—gives the familiar replacement narrative an interesting wrinkle. There is something far more unnerving about being threatened by someone calmly explaining that everything is wonderful than by someone chasing you with an axe. Even better, Kate’s resistance makes her appear increasingly irrational. When everyone else is peaceful and you are the person screaming that something is wrong, eventually even you have to wonder who the problem actually is.

The contained setting helps considerably. Shot primarily inside a single house, The Nice Ones uses confinement rather than attempting to manufacture a scale its resources cannot support. Doors, rooms, windows and conversations become increasingly oppressive as Kate realizes there may be nowhere she can retreat without encountering another smiling face. The ensemble—including Emrhys Cooper, Ayvianna Snow, Daniela Norman, James Akka, Donna Preston and Ian Whyte—helps sell the transformation because the horror depends upon subtle behavioral changes rather than elaborate effects. The movie occasionally reveals the limitations of its modest production, and there are moments when its central metaphor is more compelling than its execution, but Stylianou generally knows when suggestion is more effective than explanation. The less certain Kate becomes, the more interesting the movie gets.

What makes The Nice Ones linger is its realization that horror does not always need to arrive snarling from the darkness. Sometimes it smiles, tells you everything is going to be fine and wonders why you are being so difficult. That inversion gives Stylianou’s film a particularly contemporary uneasiness, especially in a world where certainty, positivity and righteousness can become weapons when nobody is permitted to question them. The Nice Ones may begin with strange lights in the sky, but its real horror is considerably closer to home: the moment when everyone around you insists nothing is wrong, and their reassuring smiles become the strongest evidence that you might be right.

Runtime: 89 mins
Director: Peter Stylianou’s
Writer: Peter Stylianou
Cast: Joelle Rae; Emrhys Cooper; Ayvianna Snow; Daniela Norman
Genre: Horror | Sci-fi
Tagline: They're Here
Memorable Movie Quote: "Don't Be Afraid"
Distributor: Level 33 Entertainment
Official Site:
Release Date: September 29, 2026
DVD/Blu-ray Release Date:
Synopsis: When Kate joins her boyfriend's friends at a remote countryside retreat, strange lights appear in the sky. As tensions rise, something unseen begins turning the group into eerily "nice" versions of themselves, hiding a darker truth.