From the very first cozy scene in Blind Date Book Club, you can tell Hallmark has another winner on its hands. Directed by Peter Benson and written by Nicole Baxter, this springtime romance centers on Meg (played with sincere sweetness by Erin Krakow)—a charming Nantucket bookstore owner who’s at a crossroads in life. When Meg’s quirky and beloved “blind date with a book” club earns attention from a famous author, her world gets delightfully turned upside down. It’s the perfect kind of feel-good story Hallmark excels at and one of 2024’s brightest offerings from the network.
A huge part of what makes this movie so enjoyable is the chemistry between Krakow and co-lead Robert Buckley, who plays Graham Sterling, the bestselling author drawn to Meg’s book club. Their interactions are warm, funny, and effortlessly natural, helping the romance feel earned even in its predictability. Whether they’re trading witty banter or sharing softer, quieter moments in the bookstore aisles, the duo has that easy-going spark that keeps you rooting for them. It’s got that Hallmark comfort-food energy with enough zest to keep things fresh.
What I appreciated most about Blind Date Book Club is how it balances its light romantic plot with a surprisingly thoughtful look at personal growth. Meg is grappling with the legacy of her late mother’s store and whether to keep it running at all costs, while Graham is wrestling with expectations about his writing career. Their journeys toward clarity and fulfillment give the film a bit more depth than your average made-for-TV romp, without ever losing its heart. Supporting characters—like Meg’s loyal friend and bookstore sidekick—add laughs and warmth along the way.
Of course, part of the charm is simply the setting itself. Shot with a gentle, bright aesthetic in a seaside town that practically radiates coziness, the movie feels like a warm hug—bookstore cups of tea included. It’s paced in that signature Hallmark style: no rush, just a slow unfolding of banter, connection, and growing affection. The feel-good vibe never falters, and while the ending might be easy to predict, you’ll be smiling through most of the build-up anyway.
And if you missed the original broadcast, good news: Blind Date Book Club is currently streaming on Hallmark+, making it super easy to curl up with the movie whenever you need a dose of sweetness and romance. It’s the kind of film that’s perfect for a laid-back weekend watch—especially if you love cozy characters, bookish settings, and a romance that feels like it was written just for you.
MPAA Rating: TV-G.
Runtime: 84 mins
Director: Peter Benson
Writer: Nicole Baxter
Cast: Erin Krakow; Robert Buckley; Faith Wright
Genre: Drama | Romance
Tagline: Your heart can be a real page turner.
Memorable Movie Quote:
Distributor: Hallmark +
Official Site:
Release Date: April 6, 2024
DVD/Blu-ray Release Date:
Synopsis: A Nantucket bookstore owner owner known for matching others finds love and direction in life after agreeing to review a famous author's new novel in her blind-date-with-a-book club after he visits her store.
