You’re here because you like your romance cozy, your conflicts gentle, and your small-town inns emotionally overqualified for drama! All of My Heart: Inn Love is exactly your speed. This Hallmark sequel - because the original was so very popular - reunites us with Jenny and Brian, now engaged and knee-deep in the stressful-but-wholesome world of opening a bed-and-breakfast. It’s the kind of movie where the biggest threats are storms, finances, and the possibility of someone having to wear business attire again.
The tension here is pure Hallmark gold: Brian considers returning to his high-powered Wall Street life to save the inn, while Jenny clings to their shared small-town dream. It’s not edge-of-your-seat suspense, but it is emotionally effective in a warm, low-stakes way. You know everything will work out, yet the movie still manages to squeeze a surprising amount of heart out of arguments about budgets, priorities, and rustic décor.
At the heart of the story, this sequel digs deeper than the original by shifting from “will they fall in love?” to “can love survive real-life pressure?” It explores commitment, compromise, and that terrifying moment when dreams get tested by reality. The emotional stakes feel more mature here—less about flirtation, more about partnership. It’s a reminder that romance doesn’t end after the first kiss; sometimes it intensifies when you’re picking paint colors, juggling bills, and fighting to protect a shared future.
That deeper emotional layer really strengthens the chemistry between Lacey Chabert and Brennan Elliott. Their dynamic feels more lived-in this time—more inside jokes, more shared history, and more believable friction. Chabert remains the undisputed queen of cozy romance, radiating warmth and sincerity, while Elliott balances charm with genuine internal conflict. Together, they sell the idea that this relationship has grown from sparks into something sturdier and more meaningful.
According to IMDb, the film is directed by Terry Ingram, who keeps the pacing breezy and the tone comforting. The screenplay, credited to Rick Garman and Nicole Baxter, leans into Hallmark’s strengths: heartfelt conversations, gentle humor, and misunderstandings that never get too mean or melodramatic. The writing isn’t trying to reinvent cinema—it’s trying to make you feel good, and it absolutely understands the assignment.
Overall, All of My Heart: Inn Love is sweet, predictable in the best way, and perfect for a relaxing night in. It’s comfort food in movie form—no jump scares, no emotional devastation, just love, teamwork, and a suspiciously well-run country inn. You can stream it on Hallmark+, Philo, FuboTV, or rent/buy it on Amazon and Apple TV.
MPAA Rating: TV-G.
Runtime: 84 mins
Director: Terry Ingram
Writer: Karen Berger
Cast: Lacey Chabert; Brennan Elliott; Heather Doerksen
Genre: Drama | Romance
Tagline:
Memorable Movie Quote: "You and Brian have filled this place with joy."
Distributor: Hallmark +
Official Site:
Release Date: October 7, 20217
DVD/Blu-ray Release Date:
Synopsis: Brian and Jenny are engaged and preparing for the grand opening of their bed and breakfast. But when a big storm hits Bucks County, all their plans end up sopping wet.
